Summary

  • Cleveland officials discussed the lack of diversity within the Division of Fire.

  • The division was the focus of a decades-long federal consent decree until 2013, aiming for the division to increase minority representation among staffing. Between 2015-2024, about 75% of new hires to Fire have been white men. City Council is asking Fire to define how they will address this lack of diversity in action before the division returns for budgetary requests in early 2027.

  • Cleveland Fire and Police each have an internal Applicant Review Committee (the fire department’s is 17 members) that makes hiring recommendations based on a test score and background check information.

Committee Chair Richard Starr called to order the Nov. 10 Cleveland City Council Workforce, Education, Training and Youth Development Committee meeting at 1:33 p.m. Here’s the meeting agenda.

Committee members present:

  • Starr, chair
  • Stephanie Howse-Jones, vice chair
  • Deborah Gray
  • Kris Harsh
  • Nikki Hudson
  • Tanmay Shah
  • Joe Jones (absent, excused)

Special hearing about diversity in Cleveland Fire Department

Officials from the Division of Fire, the Civil Service Commission, and the Department of Human Resources spoke. They focused on recruitment and hiring.

Here are the presentation slides on Cleveland Fire Oversight.

When the Cleveland Division of Fire was under a federal consent decree

The Cleveland Division of Fire was under a federal consent decree from 1977 to 2013. The decree aimed to “implement specific procedures for the recruitment and hiring of minorities to remedy the effects of the City’s past discrimination.” The Vanguard, an organization of Black and Hispanic firefighters, also filed complaints and class action suits regarding discriminatory practices within the division.

Under the decree, the city was expected to increase minority representation. Federal oversight ended in 2013. Since then, the Cleveland Division of Fire has again returned to a demographic makeup that does not reflect the broader Cleveland population. About 75% of hires between 2015-2024 were white men. According to information gathered by Starr, Cleveland currently has 736 uniformed firefighters. Of those, 99 (13.5%) of whom are Black, and 18 are women. 

Starr opened with his own reflection, research and concern regarding the lack of diversity within Cleveland Fire. He highlighted that Cleveland Police has seen more improvement in this regard. He said he would expect to see more interest and competition for Cleveland Fire roles from Cleveland residents, the majority of whom are not white. 

Cleveland Fire’s current hiring process

Leeanne Guzman, project director for the Cleveland Civil Service Commission, outlined the current hiring process for Cleveland Fire. That includes requirements that have been changed to increase recruitment numbers. Daryl Eatman, chief examiner for the Civil Service Commission, said applicants used to be required to submit six or seven residency verification documents to receive priority consideration as a City of Cleveland resident. They now have fewer documents to submit.

Guzman added that the National Testing Network has also approved Cleveland City Hall as a verified testing center for the Civil Service Exam. That exam is a testing requirement for all firefighter recruits. By hosting this exam in the city center, the city also hopes to attract more residents. 

The committee discussed a hiring cycle that began in 2023. In that cycle, the division received more than 1,000 applications. About 25% of applicants identified as Black or African American. Of the total applicants, more than 500 completed and passed the Civil Service Exam.

Following the exam, applicant files were anonymized for name, race, education and gender. After that, candidates were ranked based on test scores and mandatory point bonuses for military service, Cleveland residency status, CMSD credit, and seniority. The Applicant Review Committee of 17 firefighters,reviewed the top 72 scoring files and made recommendations to the division chief and director of Public Safety. The chief and director decided the 40 candidates for the class. The city hired 35 from that class.

Members of the Cleveland Documenters team at City Hall. Top row: Anastazia Vanisko, Larry Gardner, Andrea Jones, Ronaldo Rodriguez Jr, Regina Samuels, Mary Ellen Huesken, Gennifer Harding-Gosnell. Bottom row: Doug Breehl-Pitorak, Kellie Morris, Laura Redmon, Cleveland City Council Member Rebecca Maurer, Sheena Fain, Jeannine Isom-Barnhill, Jotoya Gray, Angela Rush. Credit: Anastazia Vanisko

Join the movement for transparency

Civic power can start with you! We train and pay Documenters to take notes at local government meetings and share them here. Learn more about becoming a Documenter.

Starr and Howse-Jones expressed concern that the division manages so much of the hiring process internally, without independent oversight from Human Resources, city officials, or another outside party. Howse-Jones requested that someone find out if this Applicant Review Committee existed during the era of the consent decree, though no one was able to provide this answer during the hearing. Howse-Jones would like to see some entity beyond the division supporting the work of the Review Committee for the current hiring cycle. 

Recruiting candidates for Cleveland Fire

Starr asked Fire recruiters Antoine Cruz and Lieutenant Jeremy Caldwell about the challenges with maintaining a diverse pool of qualified applicants.

Cruz said, “With the list being so large, you lose contact with these candidates.”

Cruz mentioned how this makes it hard for recruiters to educate a lot of applicants about how to prepare for the various steps of the process. Recruiters offer study tools and support around the Civil Service Exam, but that requires dedication of time and travel on the part of applicants.

Caldwell spoke to the importance of engaging with CMSD to increase recruitment in the City of Cleveland. 

Slife said he has thought a lot about how this issue impacts his Ward 15.

“The reputation in my neighborhood, frankly, is firefighters,” he said. 

He brought his own slide presentation to the hearing, trying to pinpoint what stage of the recruitment or hiring process leads to the greatest dropoff in representation of non-white applicants, especially Black Cleveland residents.

‘This is woefully inadequate’

Howse-Jones said the Division of Fire has done little since the end of the consent decree to ensure not only racial diversity but also inclusion of women. She said the division should connect with the City of Toledo and its chief of fire. That city has achieved greater diversity in their department. She suggested Cleveland fire officials ask how Toledo Fire integrated in-person and oral interviews into the hiring process.

This is not something Cleveland Fire currently has a formal process for, though Acting Chief Vince DiTeodoro said applicants do have conversations with the applicant processing team. Howse-Jones uplifted the user-friendly organization and transparency of the Toledo Fire website as an example of how to be more welcoming to recruits. 

“This is woefully inadequate,” Howse-Jones said. “To be five years [on Cleveland City Council], sometimes it’s just like we just spinning our wheels, because people in this building feel entitled to adding to the continual generational harm that is happening in our community. And people are just OK with it, and they want us to continue to go along.”

New fire chief to be named

Starr asked about the status of appointing a new chief of fire. DiTeodoro has been the interim chief since August 2026. According to Director of Public Safety Dornat “Wayne” Drummond, Mayor Justin Bibb made his selection for the new chief but has not yet disclosed this publicly. Cole said the candidate has not been notified, either.  

Shah asked all presenting entities to think about what they need from council to push this agenda forward, whether that means changes to charter language, budget allocations, or other things that council can directly support. 

There’s more: Read the full notes from this meeting by Documenter Hannah Morgan.


If you believe anything in these notes is inaccurate, please email us at documenters@signalcleveland.org  with “Correction Request” in the subject line.

Cleveland Documenters pays and trains people to cover public meetings where government officials discuss important issues and decide how to spend taxpayer money.