Summary

  • Cleveland City Council Safety Committee members asked questions about diversity in both the Division of Fire and Division of Police hiring processes.

  • The Division of Police is transitioning to lighter-colored vehicles to boost visibility in neighborhoods and show their presence in communities.

  • Committee members pushed for increased transparency and information sharing during active investigations that affect their residents.

Follow up questions

  • Are the accusations of racism and discriminatory practices by candidates for Cleveland fire chief valid, and will those accusations and any related findings be taken into consideration by the city?

  • What is the budget impact of the transition to an all-white fleet of vehicles?

This was the Oct. 28 meeting of the Safety Committee of the Cleveland City Council. The purpose of the meeting was an operational review of several Department of Public Safety divisions in preparation for council budget discussions early next year.

Scene setting: This meeting took place at Cleveland City Hall. The committee took a mid-meeting break, so the recording can be found online in two sections: part 1 and part 2. 

Meeting start: The meeting started at 9:37 a.m. with a call to order and roll call. Not all members were present at the beginning of the meeting. Some left for a portion of the meeting, but a quorum was confirmed during roll call.

Committee members present:

  • Michael Polensek (chair), Ward 10
  • Richard Starr (vice chair), Ward 5
  • Stephanie Howse-Jones, Ward 8
  • Nikki Hudson, Ward 11
  • Charles Slife, Ward 15

Department of Public Safety staff in attendance:

  • Assistant Director Christopher Viland 
  • Assistant Director Jason Shachner
  • Fiscal Manager Michael Gehlmann

‘More harm than good’: The city’s removal program has caused an increase in nuisance wildlife

Animal Care & Control: Presented by Manager Bruce Campbell and Chief Rachel Bryant.

Campbell highlighted the following:

  • reducing and removing nuisance wildlife,
  • heartworm treatments paid for through partnership with Friends of City Dogs,
  • microchip vaccine clinics,
  • and a capital project for an improved dog-walking trail behind the city kennel.

The shelter has about 40 volunteers that foster animals for adoption, Campbell said. Friends of City Dogs pays for the animals’ medical care. 

Bryant spoke about a Nuisance Wildlife Pilot Program that is underway. Each year, the number of animals they remove from properties is going up. That is an indicator that things aren’t working well because if they were, the numbers would go down.

Shachner said that when animals are removed, other animals will come in to replace them. Bryant said that the goal will now be to emphasize cohabitation rather than strict removal. The removal program has caused an increase in nuisance wildlife. She spoke about animals using human products, such as garbage cans, to get easy food and avoiding their usual prey because the other options are easier food sources for them. There are other cities that have moved to cohabitation, education, and deterrence versus removal.

Shachner said the program of removing wildlife has done “more harm than good over the past 10 years.”

Editor’s note: In the meeting, Viland said the city will still ask for money for the removal program in the 2027 budget and plans to operate removal and cohabitation efforts simultaneously.

Police using white zone cars for visibility

Division of Police: Presented by Deputy Chief Jarod Schlacht.

Schlacht highlighted a transition to more visible white zone cars, a new police headquarters, the use of the Street and Nuisance Crime Enforcement (STANCE) unit, and police academy training. He said the white vehicles will be more visible in neighborhoods. The STANCE unit has written close to 1,800 citations this year. 

Polensek asked about the justification for using more visible cars and said some cities are using stealth cars in neighborhoods to better apprehend people. Schlacht confirmed that undercover cars are not going away and can still be used for those kinds of operations.

Schlacht said 63 individuals graduated from the police academy in 2026. Polensek asked what is being done to get the message out to recruit more officers. Schlacht said their social media platforms have grown and they are working on expanding their audience. Viland said a few years ago they were having police academy classes of nine, so he wanted to recognize the increase in class sizes in such a short period of time.

See police drone operations: There are 8-9 drones used by police. The public can view drone operations on a drone transparency dashboard.

Slife asked about diversity in recruitment and if the division is recruiting from Cleveland and low-income neighborhoods. Schlacht said they are recruiting in the city of Cleveland and that the recruit classes are 64% minority candidates. 

Hudson asked about the difficulty in recruiting crossing guards. Viland spoke about the challenge of filling the role because it takes up small chunks of time in two different parts of the day, which can be disruptive to people’s other work schedules. Schlacht encouraged the public to apply. 

Diversity in Cleveland’s Division of Fire

Division of Fire: Presented by Acting Chief Vince DiTeodoro, Battalion Chief Andrew Gorski, and Acting Assistant Chief Eric Seaberry.

A portion of the discussion among the committee focused on the demographics of the Division of Fire, as well as its recruiting demographics. The report from the Division of Fire showed that its recruitment demographics over the last six years were 69.6% white males, 11.5% Black males, 9.9% Hispanic males, 3.6% white females, 1.3% Black females, and .3% Hispanic females. DiTeodoro said they want their demographics to mirror the city of Cleveland as much as they can and spoke about recruitment initiatives such as Cleveland Metropolitan School District outreach and community engagement. 

Members of the Cleveland Documenters team at City Hall. Top row: Anastazia Vanisko, Larry Gardner, Andrea Jones, Ronaldo Rodriguez Jr, Regina Samuels, Mary Ellen Huesken, Gennifer Harding-Gosnell. Bottom row: Doug Breehl-Pitorak, Kellie Morris, Laura Redmon, Cleveland City Council Member Rebecca Maurer, Sheena Fain, Jeannine Isom-Barnhill, Jotoya Gray, Angela Rush. Credit: Anastazia Vanisko

Join the movement for transparency

Civic power can start with you! We train and pay Documenters to take notes at local government meetings and share them here. Learn more about becoming a Documenter.

Polensek emphasized that there should be no hazing within the Division of Fire and that the council will not tolerate any kind of harassment or intimidation. Viland said he didn’t mind speaking on behalf of Director of Public Safety Dornat “Wayne” Drummond in saying they find that kind of behavior reprehensible and terminable and will follow through with disciplinary actions if there is such behavior.

Starr spoke about the lack of diversity in the Division of Fire. He gave statistics from the 1970s about the small number of Black firefighters and said that during a consent decree, the level rose from 4% to 20% while they were being monitored. That consent decree ended, and in 2020 there was then an all-white male class, he said. Starr asked for information about where the fall-off is when diverse candidates apply but don’t make it through the process.

Howse-Jones also asked about the candidates for the current opening of fire chief and said she is hearing that there are things on record that are troubling in nature of racism, discriminatory practices, and xenophobic behavior. She asked the committee membership to meet with the mayor’s office to discuss the applicants.

Slife spoke about data he found that showed one year there was an applicant pool that more closely matched the city’s diversity numbers and had Cleveland residents, but by the time the candidates got through the process, the class was overwhelmingly white males and non-residents. 

There’s more: Read the full notes from this meeting by Documenter Jamie Harman.


If you believe anything in these notes is inaccurate, please email us at documenters@signalcleveland.org  with “Correction Request” in the subject line.

Cleveland Documenters pays and trains people to cover public meetings where government officials discuss important issues and decide how to spend taxpayer money.