State officials on Thursday approved permits for two natural gas-fired power plants, large enough to fuel entire cities, for the private use of two data center campuses in Central Ohio. 

The approvals come despite broad opposition from citizens voiced during public comment before the Ohio Power Siting Board, the state agency that approved the utility permits. They also follow voters’ approval this month of nearly 20 bans on data centers in communities across Ohio, reflecting widespread pushback against their expansion.

Central Ohio’s data center boom draws tremendous amounts of electricity from the 13-state electrical grid, and all that new demand has helped pressure energy prices upward. Data centers’ solution has been to build “behind the meter” gas plants that tie into the tech facilities, not the general grid. This in theory allows them to facilitate the growing artificial intelligence sector without raising everyone’s electrical bills. 

The Power Siting Board granted one permit to PowerConneX for an 800-megawatt gas-fired power plant in Ashville, near Columbus, to fuel two data center buildings owned by its parent company, EdgeConneX, a Virginia-based developer. 

There, residents grew so incensed at their village council’s dealmaking with the developers that they placed a referendum on the general election ballot to repeal an emergency resolution that memorializes a development agreement between Ashville and EdgeConneX. More than 80% of locals voted to overturn the village’s arrangement with EdgeConneX.

However, the impact of the resolution is unclear in light of the Power Siting Board’s ruling Thursday. Media reports show ongoing construction at the site and the company claims in regulatory filings that the vote did not have “any effect” on either the gas plant or the data center. 

About 30 minutes northeast of Ashville, Massachusetts-based Advanced Power received a permit to build the Fairfield Energy Center, a 1,350-megawatt natural gas-fired power plant to be developed over 120 acres in Millersport. 

The electricity generated there will flow to four data centers on a $2.1 billion campus owned by Denver-based Vantage Data Centers, all a few miles from the tourist hub around Buckeye Lake. The approval follows a series of public hearings where neighbors of the project panned the data center, the gas plant and the entities behind them both. 

Signal Ohio reached out to both Vantage and EdgeConneX for comment. 

The fault lines around both projects were the same. Local government representatives and economic development officials backed the projects, emphasizing their tax and economic benefits. And the unionized tradesmen that build the plants support them for the thousands of construction jobs they provide. 

Following data centers: See all our coverage on data centers in one place — explained clearly and focused on how it affects you.

Voters back back moratoriums on data centers

But many people don’t like data centers, public opinion polling shows. Midterm election results in Ohio were telling: 18 of 18 local data center moratoriums and exclusions on the ballot across the state overwhelmingly passed. 

Why people oppose data centers varies. Some don’t like the environmental impacts of the heat-trapping or potentially unhealthy emissions of a natural gas plant needed to power the facilities; some don’t like the noise generated by their construction or daily operation; and some just don’t like the implications of the artificial intelligence models that data centers facilitate. 

While estimates vary, Ohio generally ranks in the top five states with the most data center development. A recent study in the journal Nature Sustainability found Ohio’s data centers are responsible for 2.9 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions per year, the third-most of any state, according to The New York Times. 

The developers’ interest in Ohio stems in part from, for them, a generously favorable tax code. Recent legal changes slashed property taxes for newly built power plants. And state law allows sales tax exemptions, some worth tens to hundreds of millions over their lifetimes, for capital costs on data centers or the natural gas plants that fuel them. 

Approval from the OPSB doesn’t mean the projects are done deals – some still need separate environmental permits for water discharges or backup diesel generators.