Statehouse Republicans are considering legislation that would keep a Jefferson County coal plant open after 2028, despite its previous contract with a broad swath of stakeholders to shut down.
The idea has not yet been formally introduced as legislation, though a powerful House lawmaker said Friday lawmakers will hear testimony from stakeholders this week. As of Monday, the bill had not yet been assigned a number, according to the House agenda.
The legislative session ends Dec. 31, at which point Democrats, who have pushed to pivot the state away from coal and other fossil fuels, take control of the governor’s office. Republicans also lost enough House seats to override any potential gubernatorial vetoes. That means the clock is on if Republicans want to pass something while they maintain near-total control of the statehouse.
Lawmakers see preserving a coal plant as a move to improve affordability for Ohioans – more power supply, in theory, means lower energy prices. But that comes at the cost of an environmental goal to shift the electric grid away from heat-trapping and pollution emitting fossil fuels. And some critics warn that lawmakers ripping up a signed, private contract undermines the complex negotiations that underpin energy regulations.
At issue is one of three units at the Cardinal plant, a coal-fired power station along the Ohio River in Jefferson County. Collectively, they generate enough electricity to power hundreds of thousands of homes. Affiliates of American Electric Power, an investor-owned utility company, and Buckeye Power, an electric co-operative that sources and distributes power to rural Ohioans, built the plants in the 1960s.
In 2015, AEP reached a settlement with an array of parties in a broader case at the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, a regulatory agency that sets electric prices also known as PUCO. Part of the process includes negotiations with different parties, offering concessions if they sign on to a final deal.
As part of the deal, the environmentally focused-Sierra Club signed on to support the settlement after AEP agreed to shut down the Cardinal plant’s third unit by Dec. 31, 2028. Buckeye Power paid AEP for full ownership of that unit in 2022.
A draft version of the legislation circulating among lawmakers at the statehouse, first obtained by Canary Media, would prohibit closure of coal or other power plants “solely” because of any settlement agreement.
Plant owners say energy needs have changed since deal
In a statement, Buckeye Power spokeswoman Shelby Moore said the 2015 settlement came at a time “when the region’s reliability and affordability outlook was very different.” She said the bill preserves access to electricity when it’s needed the most, but declined to answer specific questions.
“The regional electric grid that supplies power to Ohio, PJM, already faces tight generation supplies and is not meeting its reliability targets,” Moore said. “Those concerns are expected to worsen as additional power plants are scheduled to retire and as electricity demand increases.”
Energy economists have warned that the string of retirements of 20th century coal plants while data centers add exponential new levels of demand on the grid will raise electric prices and increase risks of blackouts or other reliability shortfalls. In theory, keeping the power on the grid would limit cost increases for electricity, a top-of-mind issue for voters.
But coal-fired power is far dirtier than even natural gas, let alone solar, wind or nuclear power in terms of its carbon dioxide and heavy metal emissions, hence the environmental opposition.
And state laws that let parties skirt contracts raise thorny legal questions, lawyers and energy advocates said in interviews. Settlements of PUCO cases resolve complex disputes between distribution utilities, power suppliers, major electric buyers, residential customers and others. Letting state lawmakers and regulators tear them up risks destabilizing a practice built to foster compromise and keep electric costs down.
“Changes that affect existing agreements could raise questions about regulatory certainty and potentially make future settlements more difficult to achieve,” said Maureen Willis, executive director of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel, a nonpartisan state agency that represents interests of residential ratepayers in PUCO cases.
“Our interest is in ensuring that Ohio’s regulatory processes work effectively and in the best interests of consumers,” she said.
House energy chairman says we won’t be ‘leveraged’
Neil Waggoner, a manager with the Sierra Club’s Beyond Coal campaign, said the idea violates language in the Ohio Constitution that prohibits laws that work retroactively or impair public contracts. And Nolan Ruschilling, managing director of energy policy for the Ohio Environmental Council, said the idea is not only unconstitutional but a last minute, rushed move regarding a foreseeable event.
“Rather than raise this issue anytime over the last two years, or work out a compromise with the parties in this settlement, Buckeye Power is waiting until mid-November to seek legislation because of their poor planning,” he said.
Rep. Adam Holmes, a Southeast Ohio Republican who chairs the House Energy Committee, said in an interview Friday that Buckeye Power approached lawmakers last month about the issue.
The company, he said, wants to sell power from the plant into a special auction for electricity that’s used to backstop the system during periods of unusually high demand. These are getting more common given growth in power intensive industries like data centers or heavy manufacturing, and increasingly frequent heat events.
Holmes said the issue is worthy of a public discussion but promised this won’t be a “sneaky, lame duck thing” – a reference to some of the late night, backroom deal making that define the legislative window from November elections to the start of new lawmakers’ terms in January.
Lawmakers are sensitive to the optic of “canceling” a contract, but also to Americans’ widespread frustration with rising energy costs, he said. He said he expects testimony from stakeholders like Buckeye Power, the Ohio Farm Bureau, PUCO, PJM and others.
“We’re not going to be leveraged – someone’s failure to plan does not create an emergency on our part,” he said. “We’re not going to try to rush it.”
A spokeswoman for House Speaker Matt Huffman, the ranking Republican who controls the chamber’s agenda, didn’t respond to an inquiry.
Regulator, grid operator push to keep plant open
Earlier this year, both the PUCO and PJM wrote letters to Buckeye Power CEO Craig Grooms urging him to pursue different options to keep the plant open, a pressure campaign that environmentalists referred to as oversteps from regulators and grid operators.
The company provided the two letters to Holmes, who gave them to Signal Ohio.
PJM senior vice president of operations Michael Bryson urged Buckeye to “take all necessary steps to avoid deactivation of Cardinal Unit 3 by December 31, 2028” and keep it open for at least six more years.
He suggested the company seek temporary approval from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, even though it is out of compliance with new wastewater rules for power plants that took effect in 2020. And he wrote that Buckeye can seek a voluntary waiver from its contract, or seek “other legal or equitable considerations for such period.”
Sarah Jarrett, a federal energy advocate at the PUCO, similarly urged Buckeye Power to “take all necessary steps” to stay open. She said she can’t speak to the terms of a private contract, but power demand has increased significantly since it was signed.


